Showing posts with label movie reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label movie reviews. Show all posts

Friday, January 15, 2016

"13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi" — movie review

Movie: 13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi
Length: 144 min
Rated: definitely R (language, violence)
Starring: John Krasinski, James Badge, Dale, Pablo Schreiber, David Denman, Dominic Fumusa, Max Martini, David Giuntloi

Director: Michael Bay
Screenplay: Chuck Hogan

No chance I was going to watch this. Zero interest. Michael Bay's first Transformers movie was fun, if flawed. It felt as if the second movie isolated all the flaws, multiplied them, and made a movie exclusively based on them. I came to see that this was director Michael Bay's style. He lost me as a filmgoer.

So when I learned that he was making a film about Benghazi, I wouldn't even watch the trailers. Bay, openly homosexual member of the Hollywood set, would surely have created a piece to whitewash Obama and help Hillary! Clinton. I was already irritated at Hollywood's refusal to create films uniting and encouraging America in war time as it had done in the 40s, so I was positively averse.

But then just recently I saw some buzz saying that the movie was no whitewash. While its focus isn't political one way or the other, it very plainly contradicts the changing WH narrative, I read. There's no "video," there's no protest. All the tragic events unfold deliberately and grindingly, with the White House and everyone else fully notified from the first second — and no aid is sent. They are all left to die, with zero US or other support. And the film, I read, relayed this all straight-up and well.

So then when I received an invitation from Grace Hill Marketing to attend a showing, I readily accepted.

And so?

Bottom line. First, given my readership of fellow-Christians, you do need to know this is a hard-R. Think Saving Private Ryan in terms of cursing, coarse talk, and realistic violence. Not gratuitous, in my opinion, but be advised.

That said, it is a really good movie. It was moving, frustrating, engrossing, infuriating, nerve-wracking, and impossible to look away from. Good to be reminded that Michael Bay can actually make a really good movie when he focuses his talents on some solid material and pursues it with discipline. This film is a solid testimony to the heroes and victims of Benghazi, and an eloquent indictment of the failure of the White House and State Department.

Review. Contrary to his reputation for relying on pyrotechnics and the grand scale, Bay begins with a tight focus on the former-military contractors hired to protect a covert CIA base in Benghazi. Some terse narrative and footage establishes the situation, and then we begin getting to know the men.

Despite the well-known and escalating battles to come, the men really remain the focus of the movie, true to the title. When gunfire and explosions come, though they fill the screen, they're still incidental to these grimly humorous, determined, family-loving, self-sacrificing, and utterly formidable warriors.

We meet all the men through the eyes of a new arrival, and they're all immediately immersed in a tense situation, followed by another and tenser situation. We see that their relationship with the CIA "chief" is unequal, as he shows no respect and little regard for them.

Tension is heightened artfully by the music and occasional time notations, as we see worrisome hints here and there of activity among the heavily-armed and apparently completely idle locals. We're introduced to US Ambassador Chris Stevens and his bright, doomed optimism for making friends with the people of Benghazi. Stevens has been provided with a hollow gesture of two (2!) bodyguards in this highly-dangerous setting.

Gradually and with a sense of mounting dread the stage is set for the initial attack on the compound. When it comes, and as its subsequent waves unfold, Bay's fondness (and adeptness) for explosions and pyrotechnics serve and advance the narrative well. The point of view is all over the place: on the ground, in the air, via satellite. This is masterfully done: the more I reflect on it, the more I admire that aspect.

The contractors are not portrayed as angels or saints, but as grim, seasoned professionals who know exactly what needs to be done and are determined to do it. This makes for squirming, agonizing watching, as the attacks escalate, the embassy begs for help, and the CIA chief dithers and flounders and flatly orders the contractors to "Stand down."

Finally, they can't take it any longer. The embassy pleads for their intervention:"If you do not help us now, we will die," and they feel they must respond regardless of the CIA chief. The team leader gives his men the choice to back out, since they're unauthorized and completely on their own. His team members don't even respond, simply waiting for him to go on with the plan; no one considers not diving in and helpful their fellow-Americans to the full, whatever the risk. This is heroism, and it's nice to see Hollywood represent some for a change.

We watch, knowing how it ends, hoping for a rewrite of history. Despite heroic efforts, they are unable to save Ambassador Stevens — bitterly observing that, had they been unleashed when they asked permission, they would have been able to save both him and his aide.

When the last shot is fired and a way to leave the country finally is provided, we are shaken. The audience at my screening broke out in applause.

Sad, instructive story, excellently told.

What's great about the movie? The way that Bay focuses on the central characters, paces the movie, and somehow manages to keep all the simultaneous movements on the screen. The acting is right in the groove, and of course the special effects are top-notch, down to the sound of rounds zipping past our heads.

Positive portrayals of our warriors are also to be appreciated, not assumed, in today's Hollywood, and this is an instance of it. The men are selfless in their commitment to protect fellow-Americans, committed in their bond to each other, and they go to great pains to avoid shooting non-combatants.

Let me add also about the violence: until the last part of the movie, it is for the most part distant, non-lingering, and non-focal. However, in the final sequences there are some pretty gruelling sights and sounds. But then, this is war, and not a sanitized version of it.

What's less great? Is there Gospel? I fear that the promoters are trying to market this as a faith-based or otherwise Christian-friendly film. It is no such thing, and they would not do the movie a service by selling it as such.

I know nothing of the faith of the actual men involved, but as far as what is onscreen, there is a lot of profanity, a fair dose of crudeness, and a few very general mentions of God. The one explicitly theological statement is directly anti-Christian. It's a quotation from Joseph Campbell, to the effect that "Heaven and hell are within us, and all the gods are within us." This is precisely the opposite of how we actually can know the true and living God, and is countered by the world-tilting truth of the Gospel.

There is a bit more shaky-cam than I'd rather. But it's minor enough not to be a problem.

Finally, a split-decision: I found the music to be not very imaginative or creative, sometimes no more than sustained alternating chords. But my son Josiah found it very tense and gripping, and perfectly suited to the movie.

Do you recommend it? For the person prepared for the violence and language, I do, absolutely and enthusiastically. It's a gripping tale of personal heroism and institutional ineptness, and yet another reason to refuse to cede our freedoms to bureaucrats and politicians. It does make one burn to see the inept stewards in Washington called to account for their culpable inaction.

Addendum: here is an interview with the surviving heroes of 13 Hours.

Tuesday, August 04, 2015

"Any Day" — movie review

Movie: Any Day
Length
: 98 min
Rated: unrated
Starring: Sean Bean, Kate Walsh, Tom Arnold, Eva Longoria 

Director: Rustam Branaman
Screenplay: Rustam Branaman



Preface: I virtually never enjoy giving a negative review. So I never accept an offer of, say, a movie, unless I think there's a decent chance I'll like it. In the case of "Any Day," the cast of actors, plus the sketch of a redemptive plotline, plus its presentation as a "faith-based" movie, led me to hope that it would make a decent family watch. So I accepted a review copy.

Bottom Line: Once again, I watched it with my family and in-laws. The six of us ranged in ages from 15 to 79. The verdict?

Nobody loved it, and at least one really hated it. The biggest problem could be summed up thus: this movie doesn't know what it wants to be. And that's a problem.

Review: The central character is Vian (not a typo; played by Sean Bean), a boxer and a drunk who, in the opening sequence, is provoked at a party and beats a man to death. A crowd, including his sister Bethley (Kate Walsh), watches him do it, only stepping in when it is too late.

Finger-snap, it's twelve years later, and Bean's out of prison and getting off a bus. Yes, that abrupt. He goes to his sister's house, wanting to stay for a brief time until he can get a job. She will barely speak to him and abruptly rejects him. Why? Why is she still mad at him, 12 years later? We never find out.

This is one of those bothersome things that keep this from being an enjoyable movie. Bethley is portrayed as a decent person, a churchgoing believer, who relents again and again, helping Vian. So what sense does it make for her not to have worked at their relationship while he was in jail? Now he's out and helpless. Why didn't she pick him up? Why hadn't they talked about what he'd do with his life once he got out? Why doesn't she care to help him in his clear and sincere desire to go straight? There's no hint that Vian did anything wrong during that time; his demeanor throughout is meek and defeated, not unrepentant and defiant. This jars.


So Bethley relents, Vian moves into the garage and begins looking for work. The fellow who owns his old gym is also unaccountably still mad at him and unwilling to help. Vian has no other success, since he's an ex-con, until he happens on Roland (Tom Arnold), a fellow working the 12 steps who takes a chance on him. So, one good thing for Vian.

Then, in a grocery story, Vian very aggressively and clumsily "hits on" Jolene (Eva Longoria), obviously an attractive career woman who, unaccountably, succumbs to his utterly charmless, ham-fisted, and arguably menacing pursuit.

They instantly become physically, then sexually involved (more on that, later). But Jolene has a slimy ex-boyfriend who's a stalker. (Maybe she has a "thing" for charmless men who won't take "No, no, no, no, and once again, no" for an answer?) Slimyi-ex-boyfriend/stalker remains a menacing presence until finally he turns up with a folder revealing Vian's background.

Yes, that's right! Vian never tells Jolene that he was in jail for second-degree murder. And she has shown no great curiously about his background. Oopsie! She already accepted his lack of candor about his employment, but this is a bit much. Aaand then this ex-boyfriend, having served his role as a plot-device, disappears.

That happens a few times. There's a storyline about Bethley's precocious son being bullied. He wants Vian to teach him to fight. Vian refuses. Yet, just by watching Vian, somehow this little kid succeeds in slugging the bully and sending his (all much taller) henchmen running. Then that's dropped.

Bethley invites Vian to church, he's not interested. She's pretty vague. Bethley's son and Vian have a vaguely religious conversation. Bethley has a Bible, which is left closed. At one crisis point, she tries to pray part of the Lord's Prayer. The only book Vian reads is The Old Man and the Sea, because the boy urged him to and a crisis has occurred and it contains one of the deus ex machina's.

That's the setup. I'll only tell you that everything goes to hot blazes for Vian and he hits angry, stupid, drunken bottom. Then suddenly, he's all better. His redemption? That he will attend Alcoholics Anonymous with Roland.

But it's worse than that. Things are righted through not one but at least two deus ex machina's which pop up. Maybe even two and a half.

Salvation is achieved through a bunch of unexpected money, and AA.

What's great about the movie? Nothing. Sorry; just, nothing.

The only thing that makes "Any Day" to any degree watchable is the four talented principles, who try hard to make sympathetic characters out of the stick-figures they're given to play and the forgettable dialogue they're given to speak.

What's less great? Everything other than the four leads — and the boy. The camerawork is uneven, occasionally switching to slow-motion for no detectable reason. The music is forgettable. The scenery is nothing.

But here's the thing: this movie isn't any one thing, exactly.

Is it a family film? No; to my chagrin I was shocked by some very coarse language, and an unexpected PG13 semi-clothed sex scene that went on too long. None of that was necessary. Yet neither element were so bad that the movie would not have been an R. So it wasn't a family film, and it wasn't an "adult" film. It was neither/nor.

Was it Christian? Nope. It was religious; there was a smattering of God-talk, and Bethley went to some church. What church? No idea. We only know that it gives free sno-cones.

Where's Bethley's pastor when she is at the hospital, her boy severely injured? Roland, a man with a past history of drunkenness and strippers, does show up. But no pastor. Bethley is struggling to get by, but no hint of help from her church. Unless you count the sno-cones.

But not a syllable about Christ or the Gospel, and Vian's redemption was through AA's 12 steps, and through money. There's even a gauzy glowy appearance of a character fresh out of heaven (deus ex machina number one) spouting platitudes and hinting at the location of some money (deus ex machina number two).

So people who hate religion at all will hate it, and Christians will get nothing out of it.

Also, while I don't look for elements like this to complain about, I was really troubled by the portrayal of the main female characters. Both women are attracted to men who are beneath them. Both women say "No, no, no, no" repeatedly to male characters who will not and do not ever take "No" for an answer. In real life, at least two of these situations would have been very threatening, very dangerous. All the sequences send a bad message to women and men.

Is there Gospel? Not a shard.

Do you recommend it? Sorry, but no.

I've seen worse...but that's hardly a glowing recommendation, is it?

Does Sean Bean die in this movie, too? It depends on what you mean by "die."


Friday, June 05, 2015

"Beyond the Mask" — movie review

Movie: Beyond the Mask
Length
: 103 min
Rated: PG
Starring: Andrew Cheney, Kara Kilmer, John Rys-Davis
 
Director: Chad Burns
Producers: Aaron Burns
Screenplay: Paul McCusker

Preface: Almost six years ago I reviewed an earlier Burns Family Studios production titled Pendragon: Sword of His Father. This was an independent and completely in-house production, seemingly populated by every Burns family member in creation. For all that, it was a really good effort. Some continuity issues and unprofessional acting vied for attention with other decent actors, an interesting plot, decent effects, and a true eye for beauty that resulted in memorable scenes beautifully framed.

Now the same studio makes a full-court press with Beyond the Mask. It still has plenty of Burnses involved, but the screenplay is by Paul McCusker, an accomplished writer known to Christians for his work with Adventures in Odyssey — who, since then, has sadly apostatized to Roman Catholicism.

The three lead roles are also professional actors, probably most famous of them being John Rhys-Davis, known as Sulla in the Indiana Jones movies, Gimli in the Lord of the Rings movies, and many other roles.

So what of this effort?

Bottom Line: I watched it with my family and in-laws. The six of us ranged in ages from 15 to 79. We all enjoyed it, many very enthusiastically so. We all would recommend it to anyone. It's a good, well-done family movie.

Review: the story begins in the timeframe of the signing of America's Declaration of Independence. As the movie opens, we hear the voice of the main character, William Reynolds, introducing us to "this monster called the East India Company." He is speaking guiltily to "Charlotte" — who? Why? We were intrigued.

When watching an independent production, one always begins with bated breath. Production quality is often low, if well-intentioned. First impressions cast a shadow over the rest of the experience.

In this case, opening scenes immediately and ably take us to England in 1775 and introduce us to the speaker, William Reynolds (Andrew Cheney), who serves as an assassin and intriguer for that organization. With relief, we see that the hand behind this movie has an expert eye for a beautifully-framed scene, as we often observed and remarked in reviewing Pendragon. This is our first, night-time view:

CLICK TO ENLARGE
It is the first of many beautifully framed period shots sparkling throughout the film. Later, we're shown revolutionary-era Philadelphia:


Back to the start: this peaceful view immediately bursts into action, in almost a steampunk sniper situation. Protagonist Reynolds and his assistant briskly set up and launch a mission to replace critical documents that would have been damaging to the EIC. After this Reynolds hands over the unfavorable report to EIC employer, Charles Kemp (John Rhys-Davies). We learn that Reynolds wants out; he's had enough of his life as an assassin, and wants to live a new life enjoying the rewards that Kemp promised him. Kemp pleads with him to stay on and be his man in America, but Reynolds is resolute.

As it turns out, the EIC's retirement plan for Reynolds involves planting a bomb on the carriage that he thinks will bear him to his new life. However, on the road, a clergyman-to-be sees the bomb's sparks, and rides in pursuit to warn the carriage. In the ensuing action, Reynolds' rescuer is killed and Reynolds is wounded. He takes on the identity of the erstwhile vicar, and rides to the vicar's new church, to take on his duties and his life.

When he arrives, he is half-dead, and must be rescued by the lovely Charlotte Holloway (Kara Killmer). In the ensuing developments, Reynolds recovers and makes a shaky start as vicar to a very (very!) gracious little congregation, and his relationship with and feelings for Charlotte blossoms.

Reynolds eventually wants to marry Charlotte, but he has not been honest about his past. When his old boss learns he's not dead yet, our hero once again is targeted, and eventually flees. Reynolds means to earn Charlotte's love by undoing some of his wrongs and becoming a hero to the patriots in America. He becomes a sort of Zorro figure, a masked man on a horse, rescuing those in peril and thwarting the violence of the East India Company conspirators.


Reynolds eventually thwarts an assassination attempt, but in the effort he is himself framed as the assassin, which is all too easy to do, given his past. All looks dim. Reynolds has lied to Charlotte, he's failed in his attempt to earn grace, and he's about to be hanged. What will happen?

At this point, to continue the narrative would be to spoil the plot. So:

What's great about the movie? Scene after scene, as I've mentioned, is simply beautiful. Since the movie was all shot in modern Michigan, obviously some must be CGI — yet it's done flawlessly and well. The CGI has to be supplemented with real sets and, as in Pendragon, they are all very well-done and authentic as well.

There are many action sequences, involving pursuits, fist-fights, sword-fights, shooting, and explosions. They're all done really excellently, top-notch. There's even a rooftop pursuit:


This is no small matter. I've recently seen studio movies, fully financed and done by "professionals," which fudge the action scenes by nauseatingly shaky-camera shots, or snip-snip-snip over-editing. This movie does neither. The climactic scenes even go steam-punk on us, in a mostly-successful (more in a moment) reach.


The acting of the principals is all well done, including the actor who plays Benjamin Franklin (!). There are no distracting dead-notes as there were in Pendragon. The dialogue is largely believable and largely natural. There are touches of humor, and a number of surprising plot-twists.

In most scenes the music is lush and appropriate, and highlights either the action or the mood of the scene.

The plot is interesting and involving, and largely moves right along to resolution, holding our interest.

What's less great? There are no elements that spoil the movie, though if I didn't mention a quibble or two, you'd think it wasn't me. For my part, I kept being taken a bit out of the lovely scenes by the lighting. These were outdoor or indoor scenes, yet the actors faces and clothes would shine brightly white on the sides with what was clearly theatrical lighting, not anything like ambient light. It was so pronounced as to distract me several times.


My dear wife noted that, though the last part of the movie was June-July, the actors' breath made steam, even indoors. She also wondered where the rather anachronistic cabling came from in a strategic sequence.

My older son Josiah, with his eye for detail on all matters relating to weaponry, squawked a couple of times when actors holding what were supposed to be flintlock pistols carried them aimed straight into the air. That's the proper way to carry a modern pistol; it would have been disastrous with a flintlock pistol.

I felt the whole imposter-vicar portion of the movie was brushed by. After the initial scene, we were given nothing to help us understand how a fellow who clearly knew nothing about religion carried off this

Is there Gospel? Yes, clearly enough but very briefly. It's a Christian movie, or Christianoid — given that the writer is a Roman Catholic; but it's not a movie about Christianity.

Do you recommend it? Yes, very enthusiastically so. As I said, we all enjoyed it, men and women, young teens and almost-eighty. It's very well-done from start to finish.

This movie is being released to theaters today, June 5. If it is playing near you and you're looking for a family movie, this is a great pick. It will be even better on a big screen with big sound.

The Burns Family Studios continues to strive for excellence in moviemaking. I look forward to future productions!

Thursday, September 04, 2014

"The Identical" — movie review

Movie: The Identical
Length: 107 min
Rated: PG
Starring: Amanda Crew, Ashley Judd, Seth Green, Ray Liotta, Joe Pantoliano, Blake Rayne
Director: Dustin Marcellino

I was offered screening tickets on this movie, which will be released tomorrow, September 5, 2014. The trailer looked iffy, to a jaded and oft-blackened eye. Was this going to be yet another by-the-numbers parody of fundamentalist Christians, written by people who neither personally know nor like any actual Christians? Would the son be all deep and conflicted and "I just gotta follow my dream, Daddy!", and would the father be all "Then roast in Hell, demon-child, with that Hellish rock and roll of yours!"? The trailer sure looked like it could be.

Boy, I'm glad we didn't see that movie.  Oh, sorry — should have said "spoiler alert."

At any rate, despite the trailer, "The Identical" had possibilities, and it had "Date Night" written all over it, so the missus and I escaped to the showing. We were both braced but, as usual, set ourselves to maintain open minds.

The opening scenes were a very strong frame-setter, taking us back to the Great Depression in black and white footage. We are introduced to a couple (the Hemsleys) trying to make a living in a jobless economy, and eventually dealing with the birth of twin boys. Enter pastor Reece Wade (Ray Liotta) and his wife Louise (Ashey Judd), conducting a "revival" in the area. Father attends, and is struck by an idea by inspiration.

Now, here is a typical juncture that touches on my slightly conflicted feelings about the movie. The first words from this southern preacher are very clearly about God's love for people of all races. Whew, one obvious and well-traveled stereotype dodged. Then the preacher slides aside to share personally about his and his wife's disappointment in a recent miscarriage, frustrating their desire to have a child. They're both in tears, and he asks all there to pray for them.

You see? It's a sweet moment, in itself: human, personal. Pastor and wife are treated like multi-dimensional human beings, and likable ones at that. That's very much in the "plus"-column, and at variance from the usual "all-Fundamentalists-are-shallow-hypocritical-hateful-cartoonish-racists" script.

And yet, there's not the least preaching of the Gospel per se, despite the "revival" setting. Not a whiff.

More on that later.

Regardless, this plants an idea with the twins' dad, which eventually is accepted by their mom: give one of the twins to pastor and wife to raise. The Wades are reluctant at first, and they actually try to give money to the destitute Hemsleys to help them (— another welcome step aside from the stereotypical portrayal of all pastors as greedy takers). In the end, the Wades accept the boy, and the Hemsleys conduct a fake funeral to explain the twin's absence.

This becomes the frame for a sort of "What if Elvis Presley's stillborn identical twin had lived, and had been raised by different parents?" story. Drexel, the boy raised by his birth parents, becomes a famously successful rock singer, whose style and look and trajectory is very like Presley — down to concerts, TV spots and corny movies.

And what of the other twin, Ryan? There are pleasantly authentic scenes of Pastor Wade trying to get little Ryan to memorize his Bible (only singing the verses works for him), and attend church. Again, the parents are sympathetic and likable, but no specific Gospel is preached. One never really finds out what Ryan believes. (In fact, one never finds out a great deal of what the preacher-father believes.) Ryan tries Bible school, but he doesn't feel "the call." What Ryan does feel is love for rock and roll. He goes to a "speakeasy," sings, and eventually (post-military-stint) finds a career doing concerts, playing unknown twin brother Drexel's music. Ryan looks and sounds so much like Drexel that, in fact, that he is billed as... wait for it... "The Identical."

Both twins are played by newcomer Blake Rayne. He's adequate and plenty likable, and one isn't surprised to learn that he won an Elvis impersonator competition.

So, what'd we think of the movie?

We liked it, basically. And we recommend it. It really is a "family-friendly" movie. There isn't a bad word or salacious syllable or image in it. We chuckled a number of times.

While we never really learn what Ryan thinks about Jesus or the Gospel, he does love and appreciate his parents who raised him, and they love him. To the end, Liotta and wife are sympathetic characters, and virtually every stereotype is dodged. The only truly odd thing about them is that Liotta's character ages dramatically — but his wife stays pretty much the same.

Yet, as characters, they are easy to sympathize with. Usually it is obvious that the screenwriters viscerally hate what they think Christians are in general, and what they think clergy are in particular. In this case, none of that could be found here.

The Identical won't make the starry annals of all-time great moviemaking, but it is fun and pleasant. There are a number of genuine laughs. Loved the presence of Seth Green and Joe Pantoliano, both of whom are a lot of fun and clearly had a good time with their roles.

The survey I was given after the screening asked questions along the lines of whether I'd recommend taking church groups or in other ways making the movie a church activity. My answer was no. I was astonished to learn that pastors have developed some sort of teaching to parallel the movie. I don't see it as having any very particular Gospel or Biblical tie-in whatever.

That said, it would make for a pleasant family watch, with a very 50s feel. After that, you could discuss what was missing (HEL-LO! THE GOSPEL), and the fact that for all his obvious love for his son, Dad seemed a lot more concerned that Ryan feel "the call," and a lot less concerned that he have saving faith in Christ.

Final word: worst possible reading. This has been a charitable review. However, the advertising really stresses the follow your dreams theme, and injects the notion that if God is in your dreams, nothing can stand against them. This, thankfully, is not as heavy-handedly preached in the movie. I don't even recall Ryan making that connection once... and that's a good thing.

While non-Christians apparently love that message, I think the promoters are unwise to stress it insofar as they want to reach out to Christians. Because that idea is in fact peddled today as a substitute for the Gospel, and it bears no resemblance. The Gospel is about my ruin in sin, my alienation from God, and the truly amazing work of God in Jesus Christ to reconcile sinners to Himself. None of that is in the movie. That the Christians are likable, real people is a refreshing change in a movie, and that's worth something.

But it isn't the Gospel.

Friday, April 05, 2013

Roger Ebert (1942-2013)

My day won't start the same as every previous Friday for many years.

For as long as it's been online, I've gone to www.rogerebert.com every Friday to see what movies Roger Ebert is reviewing. I wouldn't read every review, just the ones that interested me, and always the reviews of movies I was considering taking Valerie to see. Garth Franklin is right to call Ebert "America's most famous film critic, probably the most famed film critic in the world over the past few decades."

It wasn't that I always agreed with Ebert; often, I didn't. His review of Fellowship of the Rings is an example of the worst kind of review (second only to the L. A. Times' review of Cujo, which unintentionally revealed that the reviewer had not seen the complete movie). Though he gave FOTR three of four stars, Ebert criticized it for not being the movie he'd have made from the book — which shouldn't be the point of a review.

Nonetheless that review, like all of Ebert's reviews, was written with style and vigor. That's why I read him. Ebert was frequently funny, always opinionated, often informative. When he liked a movie, I often could tell from his reasons that I would hate it; and often when he disliked a movie, the reverse dynamic would obtain. He tended to love sensitive, positive portrayals of immoral people and behavior; and tended to hate patriotic, moral movies — but only "tended." He wasn't utterly predictable. Nonetheless, Ebert would usually give me enough to make an informed decisions: try it out, or avoid like the plague.

I've known of him for decades, since watching him with Gene Siskel in their Sneak Previews / At the Movies shows. Their banter was lively and fun, and not always completely friendly. But they took the occasional moral stand against exploitive movies, such as no critic takes today.

I was sad to learn of Ebert's death to cancer yesterday. It's always sad to read of the death of someone who gave no evidence of being prepared to die. Just a few weeks ago Ebert wrote of his Roman Catholic faith... if you can call it that. His conclusion:
I consider myself Catholic, lock, stock and barrel, with this technical loophole: I cannot believe in God. I refuse to call myself a atheist however, because that indicates too great a certainty about the unknowable. 
There it is: Roman Catholic, except for all the specifics. That has never failed to boggle my mind. Why would anyone choose to identify himself with a religion whose main advertised selling-point is that it is infallible in its official teachings, alone in its claim to be the true church, completely unified thanks to the Magisterium, and thus invested with the right to totalitarian authority over the lives and thoughts of its members — only to disagree with just about everything that church teaches?

Yet that's what autonomy does, and Ebert was proudly and loudly autonomous in his thinking to his last public statements. Of two things concerning which he did not have an atom of actual grounded or empirical knowledge, Ebert made this dogmatic assertion: "I was perfectly content before I was born, and I think of death as the same state."

He was foolishly betting, not merely absent data, but in the face of it. We just celebrated the grand counter to Ebert's tragic miscalculation: the bodily resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead, the climax of a complex of events fraught with meaning and significance. That Ebert chose to ignore Christ's significance says nothing about Christ, and many sad things about Roger Ebert.

Nor did Ebert heed the Lord's half-brother's warning (James 5:13-16). On April 2, Ebert said "I am not going away," and announced confident plans for the future.

Then on April 4, Roger Ebert died.

As I always do, I will cherish the hope that Ebert thought better before God's generosity reached its end (Rom. 2:4), that God awoke Ebert to his need and God's provision in Jesus Christ.

But for me in the meanwhile, I'll likely think sadly of Roger Ebert every Friday, as I'll want to turn to his witty, insightful reviews. I don't have a sixth-favorite reviewer, much less a second-favorite. There just wasn't anybody like Roger Ebert. And now he's gone.

Would that his many admirers would reflect on the inevitability of death, find the fear of God, and make the preparations which Roger Ebert never shared that he had made.

Saturday, July 16, 2011

"Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2" — movie review

Movie: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2
Length: 130 minutes
Rated: PG-13
Starring: Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Emma Watson, Alan Rickman, Ralph Fiennes
Director: David Yates


(Almost entirely) SPOILER-FREE:
The Movie Qua Movie

One-word review: wow.

I can't imagine seeing HP7B with no familiarity at least with the preceding moves (though you could try with Gilbert Cruz' game attempt to sum it all up in five minutes), so I'll assume knowledge of The Story Thus Far. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 starts on an ominous note, pauses for a pre-dive breath, and then plunges into a narrative from which it seldom comes up for air.

Everything works here. All the actors are note-perfect, the special effects are top-notch and ubiquitous to the point where they are as naturally interwoven as the beautiful landscapes in the Lord of the Rings movies, the music punctuates the story unobtrusively yet effectively, the camerawork is deft, and the pace is relentless. As a movie, HP7B is a nearly unqualified success. (For a movie that isn't about lesbian zombie anti-Christian anti-American communists to garner 97% positive rating from Rotten Tomatoes' 208 reviews, with a 100% rating from its "Top Critics," is a rare feat.)

It is simply a marvel to view making-of sequences such as this one and this one, to realize the (no pun intended) wizardry that goes into crafting this movie. One literally never knows when he is viewing London or the beauties of Scotland, or when it is a sound stage and software. But real artistry goes into this movie on every level.

Of course, technical fireworks alone could not make up for wretched writing or poor acting. (You did see the Star Wars Episode 3, right? Enough said.) So, how were the actors, one by one?

Last movie, Emma Watson's Hermione Granger was the scene-stealer. She's a marvel and a heart-breaker once again (more on that below). However, this time the stand-out performance is Alan Rickman's Severus Snape. Through his career Rickman has proven himself to be an actor of great ability and depth, capable of both comedy and drama. However, for 7 movies his portrayal of Snape has been held to the book's relatively narrow depiction of the professor as an angry, dark, seemingly negative yet enigmatic figure. The narrative line finally allows Rickman to explore and bring out this character's unseen depths and, oh my, does he.

To say that Rickman's performance singularly remains in the mind amid so many stellar actors is to say something, indeed. Last time I complained of Dan Radcliffe's limited range in portraying Harry Potter. I have  recently seen Radcliffe say in interviews that this is his only performance in this series that he can watch without a cringe, feeling he's done his best work. Agreed. I don't think Radcliffe left an empty shelf in his repertoire, bringing out the conflict and misery and force and determination of the series' titular center very movingly.

Watson and Rupert Grint shine yet again, but this is expected. It is Julie Walters and Maggie Smith who finally are given the opportunity to show what Molly Weasley and Professor McGonagall really had "under the cover," so to speak. And Ralph Fiennes fills the screen with Voldemort as one of the more despicable and dangerous movie villains in recent genre films.

The only disappointments are once again Michael Gambon's Dumbledore and, to my surprise, Robbie Coltrane's Hagrid. Gambon has boasted that he doesn't bother to read the books that are adding to his wealth, and it has shown. In a scene that calls for conflicted layers of joy, regret, guilt and satisfaction, Gambon brings no greater flavor than that of a slice of processed cheese: barely adequate, reads the lines all right, and not much more. Of all the cast, one can now say that he was the poorest choice — which is unfortunate, given the centrality of Gambon's role.

As to Coltrane, after one outburst, a scene calling for deep emotion from Hagrid was given nothing but flat grimness, which was less than I expected of him.

To give one more fine character actress a nod, Helena Bonham Carter studied video of Emma Watson so as to do Watson's Granger appearing as Carter's Bellatrix Lestrange. The result is beautiful to behold. Think of it: First, we see Carter playing Watson playing Hermione. Then we have Carter playing Watson playing Hermione playing Carter playing Bellatrix. It is perfection in acting, from facial expressions to physicality.

Deathly Hallows Part 2  is dark in tone and emotionally intense. In particular, once the story reaches a scene in a boat house, the emotional screws begin tightening inexorably. This intensifies through an increasing arc in which the art of Rickman, Ratcliffe and Watson might move a stone to reach for a hankie.

This chapter's darkness and intensity and fantasy-violence make the movie a poor choice for younger or more "sensitive" children. However, it is refreshing that no Michael-Bay-like cretin felt the need to add the slightest salacious sniggers or profanity (other than one harsh word that I noted in a climactic scene).

In sum: The two hours and ten minutes both speed by, and feel as if one's gotten three hours worth of plot, character and action. How did they do that? Movie-making magic.

WARNING: increasing spoilers ahead. Don't want them? Stop!


...


You read that, right?


...


If you go on, it's on you.


...


All right, then:



The Movie qua Adaptation (spoilers)

I'm a purist and a bit of a Potterhead — if standing in line at midnight to get the book when it came out, taking time off work and reading straight through it day and night with my dear wife; and standing (sitting) in line seven hours with my dear Josiah, qualifies me as a Potterhead — and I was absolutely delighted with it. Everything I most hoped would be done well was done well, and much of it even better than hoped.

Of course I would have gladly watched a five-hour movie that gave time for a great deal more of the book and its dialogue, but that is unrealistic.

My dear wife (a rigorous and unsparing critic) and I agree that the adaptation was done masterfully, with only a couple of exceptions, which will be noted below. We agree with virtually everything that was dropped (e.g. dropping a bothersome gnat of a character tagging along with "Bellatrix" in Gringott's), and are happy with virtually every change.

After mourning at Dobby's grave for a moment, Harry tears right into Griphook and Ollivander. He has squared his shoulders, and is driving on for the goal with no more distractions or bypaths. There is no time for the book's debates and dickering, and one doesn't miss it. A brisk if uncomfortable agreement with Griphook, a dose of Polyjuice, the quartet is off for Gringott's, and the pacing virtually never slows but for occasional necessary pauses.

Gringott's dragon is one instance of respect for the source material. With artistic eloquence, we are shown through sight and sound (not exposition) that the goblins have sorely abused and mistreated this fearsome creature. The encounter with the goblins is thrilling, but not drawn out, and Harry when plunged in the water gets a plot leg-up from his connection to Voldemort. Again, the narrative spares us the book's repeated speculations about Voldemort's awareness and the process of his checking Horcrux locations, instead making him aware of the "death" of each item, and showing Harry feeling the same.

The first bit I really wanted to see handled well was, of course, Voldermort's murder of Snape, and Harry's subsequent viewing of his memories. It was pitch-perfect. Rather than directly portraying the murder on-camera, Yates shows the trio hearing the sounds, which are more brutal and heart-stopping than if we had watched it ourselves. Voldemort departs, Harry rushes to his dying nemesis, who imparts his memories, urges Harry to view them, and says what the book only hints: "You have your mother's eyes" — and dies.

The viewed memories then ratchet up the emotional weight, showing the side of Snape never truly seen before. As in the book, we start with Lily, Petunia and Snape as children, then move on into adulthood. Here technology once again serves the story, making it possible to de-age Alan Rickman so he can portray a younger Snape.

The movie's additions to the book make still clearer Snape's undying love for Lily, his devastation over her murder at Voldemort's hands, his manipulation by Dumbledore into being Harry's reluctant guardian — and his horror at Dumbledore's setting up Harry "as a pig to be slaughtered." When Harry reels back from the Pensieve, clutching at his heart, the intensity almost reaches its climax — but not yet.

For me that climax comes in three movements. The first is just afterwards, when the movie again veers from the book. Harry does not sneak out of the castle under the Invisibility Cloak. Instead, he meets Hermione and Ron and tells them what he has figured out (that he himself is a Horcrux), and what is about to happen. "I think you figured this out days ago" he says to Hermione, and then it comes. Her face crumples into tears and she barely manages, in a small voice, "I'll go with you," then embraces him, sobbing. Heartbreaking, and actually more emotionally satisfying than the book.

The next comes in Harry's encounter with his parents, Lupin, and Sirius, in the forest — though it is odd he goes from his mother to Sirius, ignoring his father. Was that a deliberate reflection of how his father's memory was tarnished for him by what he'd learned of the abuse Snape suffered? Or just a screenwriter's glitch?


The third is, of course, when Harry walks into Voldemort's rabble, to die.

This is followed by Harry's encounter with Dumbledore at King's Cross. Though Dumbledore repeats the phrase, adding stress, one wonders how many will catch the Gospel allusions intended by Rowling. Regardless, it moves the story on to Harry's final encounter with Voldemort.

Harry's final battle with Voldemort varies considerably from the book. In the book, the encounter is almost perfunctory. Harry and Voldemort talk at some length, but Voldemort casts his spell and dies, bang. The movie draws it out at length. That might have bothered me more if I hadn't already been aware of the decision, going in. As it is, I feel that the battle was well-paced and well-choreographed, leading to a satisfying climax.

Then comes the end-scene nineteen years later, the friends (and Ginny) aged as well as technology can do, seeing their own children back to what one presumes is a rebuilt Hogwarts. Harry's moving words to his son, Albus Severus — that he is named after two Hogwarts headmasters, the second of whom was the bravest man he has ever known — lose none of their power. Satisfyingly and appropriately, the camera lingers on the three friends who have been the narrative center of all eight movies, and we are done.

I close, singling out two pluses and two minuses.

First and second plus: my dear wife and I really hoped that the characters of Minerva McGonagall and Molly Weasley, criminally mishandled in the movies, would finally get their due. They did. It is almost as if the writes felt guilty, enhancing McGonagall's encounter with Snape into a bold duel, and then highlighting her again in leading the defense of the castle.

Molly's duel with Bellatrix feels a bit hurried, but my fear was that it would be deleted altogether. One only glimpses Bella attacking Ginny, then Molly shoves her aside, growls "Not my daughter, you [bad, bad woman]," and the duel is on. Bella's confident smile is knocked away, and Molly very satisfyingly dispatches her. Applause from the audience.

The first minus is relatively minor. Much has been made of Harry's scar, for eight movies. Nothing is made of its absence. I had to ask my family if we were even shown that it was gone. They say it was. I did not see it. This deserved more emphasis.

But worse is the virtual elimination of the Gospel element Rowling intended and crafted and built up to. One wonders how she tolerated its elimination. However, by all I've seen her say and do since, I do not get the impression that Gospel proclamation is a great priority to her.

In the book, Harry makes a big point to Voldemort of the fact that he is failing to kill the children of Hogwarts, that his spells keep missing. He explicitly explains that this is because his sacrifice of himself in love has shielded them, so that Voldemort can no longer directly harm them. This is the second major occurrence of this theme, the first being Harry's mother's shielding of him by giving her life for his. Harry takes on himself the curse (Horcrux), dies, destroys it, and thus delivers Hogwarts. Then the last enemy is defeated by the Harry, who has come back to life.

Love it, hate it, criticize it, Rowling's attempt to echo the Gospel events is crystal-clear to a close reading. (Though, of course, much is missing from what would be a fuller development of the Gospel per se. It is a story, not a sermon or tract.)

The move simply dispenses with this crucial plot-point. In its stead, movie-Voldemort is simply told that his want isn't working well for him. Also, in the book Harry urges him to repent, persistently calling him "Tom"; not in the movie. Voldemort is simply given up as hopeless. Disappointing. Again I wonder: did Rowling even try to preserve that element?

Also missing, but less of a loss: the theme of Voldemort seeking the Deathly Hallows in order to become immortal and invincible. They're introduced and explained in a wonderful sequence during 7A, but in 7B they're just there. Nothing much is made of the threat they pose in Voldemort's hands, of the fact that Harry at one point possesses all of them.

One could wish for "Director's cuts" that would restore critical missing elements to all the movies, but the most important omissions (for all I know) were never scripted nor filmed. Maybe my children or grandchildren, should the Lord tarry, will see a re-visiting of this (and The Lord of the Rings) that is equally adept but more leisurely, and more respectful of the source-material.

In final sum: this franchise has gone out with a tremendous bang. This movie is the best of the lot. Eight thumbs up.

Monday, November 22, 2010

"Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1" — movie review

Movie: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1
Length: 27 min (we say; they say 146 min)
Rated: PG-13
Starring: Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Emma Watson
Director: David Yates


SPOILER-FREE SECTION

The seven Harry Potter books had one author, but the first seven Harry Potter movies have had several different directors and writers — and it has shown. The cinematic approach has morphed from filmed-book (The Sorcerer's Stone, movie #1) to movies-inspired-by-the-book (The Order of the Phoenix, movie #5). Every Harry Potter fan will have his own choice as to what has been the best or worst movie, but in my view, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1 is the best of the seven.

The movie takes off shortly after the events of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, which ended with Professor Snape killing Albus Dumbledore, Harry purposing to leave school to pursue dark wizard Voldemort, and his friends Hermione Granger and Ron Weasley pledging to join him.

As the movie opens, we find new Minister of Magic Rufus Scrimgeour (Bill Nighy) trying to encourage the wizarding world amid the dark times looming. It's an effective opening to a movie that is significantly darker than all the preceding.

Then we find the three friends independently making preparations to travel — but where to? This question of "What do we do now?" looms large over the entire movie, as Dumbledore seems not to have given Harry the specifics of what comes next. The fate of the wizarding world lies in the hands of three teen-agers; and not the wizarding world alone, but the non-magical world as well. Voldemort means to purge the magical world of opponents and the "impure," and to force Muggles (non-magical people) down to slavery, by killing or controlling them, or sexually assaulting them at airports.

Okay, that last part is someone else's idea of "inconvenient but necessary"; Voldemort might find it amusing, though. On which subject (Voldemort, that is; not harassing citizens), we see a good deal more of Voldemort in this movie, observe the intimidation and terror under which even his supporters live. In a very effective early scene, Jason Isaacs's Lucius Malfoy vividly communicates a character about to jump out of his skin for fear of Ralph Fiennes' silky, serpentine Voldemort.


It is a scene eloquently tense for its understatedness, at a long table-full of perfectly-cast actors convey an atmosphere of drum-tight tension, as a victim (barely noticed until the end) hovers overhead, effectively paralyzed.
An aside: oddly, famed critic Roger Ebert wrote, "The film opens with a frightening meeting of the Ministry of Magic, plotting the destruction of all three young heroes." Which is fine, except that (A) it isn't the film's opening, (B) it isn't a meeting of the Ministry of Magic, and (C) they do not even mention Ron or Hermione, who are of no interest to Voldemort, whatever. Otherwise, spot-on.
It is this sort of scene that marks the excellence of this seventh installment. Director David Yates and cinematographer Eduardo Serra show an eye for eloquent subtlety, which is far more effective than ham-fisted statements. Yates' actors do not say, "Boy, I am really scared/worried/devoted/defiant" — instead (listening, George Lucas?) they show it, and the camera-composition and directions convey mood and feeling in deftly-composed shots and vignettes. Ron and Hermione, asleep, their hands stretched out to one another, but not quite touching. Hermione saying "We're alone," as the camera draws back and darkness envelops the three.


Further, Yates eschews most director's addiction to endlessly splicing together one-face shots. Rather, he allows his actors to frame the shot together and react off of each other. The result is some marvelous sequences, from large ones such as Voldemort's "board meeting," to a scene involving many of the major characters about to transfigure into the same character.

The heart of the film is the relationship between the three principles, and they have never been better. My dear wife and I feared, in the fifth movie (Order of the Phoenix) that Emma Watson had forgotten how to act. No longer. Watson's embodiment of Hermione Granger is note-perfect, by turns moving, touching, amazing, and deftly, hysterically funny. No less skilled is Rupert Grint as Ronald Weasley, given the task of showing loyalty and love, despair and anger — all of which he does as if born to the role.


Unfortunately, Daniel Radcliffe's Harry is probably the least effective. Radcliffe is not a poor actor, but he is of limited range, and this movie shows it. Radcliffe's voice seems only to vary in volume rather than pitch, and his range of facial expression falls well short of Grint's. Perhaps it reflects Radcliffe's vision of Harry, because in a scene where the one actor portrays seven different actors as one character, he's very creative and clever. But mostly he either looks expressionless, unhappy, or a bit peeved. More would have been better.

At 146 minutes the movie is long, yet it moves right along, though not mindlessly so. The pacing pauses to deepen the plot, then plunges into action. For instance, one scene involving Harry and Hermione moves wordlessly from sadness, to laughter, then back to sadness. There are mad chases, explosive fights, sudden attacks; dances, flights, debates.

Though one might wish that John Williams had returned to score the final movie, Alexandre Desplat's score is very effective, now sighing and slinking, now jolting and thrilling, punctuating the action on the screen. The effects are amazing, with one exception: the Patronuses, luminous creatures summoned by the wizards. This has long been a geeky gripe of mine. The books make a good deal out of Harry's fully-formed stag Patronus, which first appeared as described in the third movie (Prisoner of Azkaban) — but Yates or his crew unaccountably traded that in for gauzy, indistinct, barely-identifiable luminescences. Animals that should be easily recognized — which is an important plot-element — instead are vague and sometimes formless.

By contrast the elf Kreacher, barely seen as a last-minute addition in The Order of the Phoenix, is perfectly realized here, and fully inhabits the frame with the flesh-and-blood actors.

Will the movie make sense to anyone who hasn't seen the previous movies, or read the books? I doubt it, at this point. A lot of essential backstory is assumed, and I think it'd be hard to come up to pace without it.

To Christians who reject the series on principle, this movie emphasizes an important point: magic is not held out as something to be aspired to. For one thing, there is an unbridgeable gap between the magical world and the common. Magic cannot be attained, in author Rowling's world. One is born magical, or he is not. Second, the magical world is ugly. Their justice system is unjust and powerless, and those wielding power are often flawed, petty, dangerous.

How does the movie rate in terms of faithfulness to the book? Overall, I'd rate the movie very well, far better than the preceding two. Most of the changes Yates introduces actually enhance the story, with exceptions that I will note in the Spoiler section.

In pre-spoiler sum: would I recommend it? Enthusiastically yes, if you enjoy dark fantasy of this kind. I would caution that the PG-13 is to be taken seriously, and I wouldn't bring younger, more impressionable children unfamiliar with the story. There is a fair bit of magical violence, a touch of harsh language and sensuality, and dark, tense tones.

Finally: Watch for the Bible verse on the headstone of Harry's parents. I expect to revisit this with you when the final movie is released, next July.

Now: read no further, if you haven't seen the film and/or read the book.

***

***

***

***

SPOILER-HEAVY NOTES — for true Potterheads

One change absolutely baffles me: why in the world is Dobby still dressed as a slave, and why in the world does Yates omit Harry putting a sock in Dobby's grave? Movie-Dobby proudly proclaims that he is a free-elf... still wearing that pathetic sack of a garment. Then Harry buries him, and I'm waiting for him and Ron to lay a sock with him, and perhaps Hermione a scarf — but nothing. Why? It was such a touching element in the book, would have taken fifteen seconds and no special-effects money, and would have deepened the emotional resonance of the scene. This omission makes no sense at all.

Another scene really irritates me: Hermione, my favorite character, is being tortured upstairs. In the book, it is clear that it is Harry's fault they are captured, and so it is Harry's fault that Hermione is tortured — and his lack of remorse after is something that bothers me about the book. At least Ron is frantic, hearing Hermione's screams, desperate to escape and save her.

But the movie is far worse. They can all hear Hermione, their best friend and often their savior, screaming in fear and pain... and, after initial distress, they pretty much forget her. Oh, hi Luna. So you're here? Cool! Ollivander, huh? I'll be. Oh, and look, Dobby! Excellent. So, Dobby, you just take these good people out while Hermione distracts the enemy by screaming in agony under unknown torture upstairs, and we'll just wait right here....

Really. Bothers. Me.

Now here's a funny thing. The filmmakers didn't see fit to include Sirius' mirror in movie #3, so Harry never broke it, so he doesn't have a shard of it. But that shard needed as a plot-device in this movie, so... presto! Here it is. With no explanation whatever, and no real surprise on Radcliffe's expressionless face when he appears to see Dumbledore in it, or the windows of some room when his forest should be reflected.

I just think that's funny. Did they say, "Maybe no one will notice"? Anyone who hasn't read the books will be absolutely clueless ("So where'd he get the magic mirror-piece?").

That said, I'd rather they just hum a little tune and slip it in, than invent some new device to save them from their earlier omission. It is an element that will become important... or, should, if they hew to the book.

I'm regretful that they haven't given Harry green eyes, and stressed in the narrative that Harry's green eyes mirror his mother's green eyes. There's a moving scene in the remainder of the book which they'll obviously be unable to film as written, as a consequence. Pity, that, with colored contact lenses so readily available.

There are odd notes, as well. Nobody seems too shook-up over Mad Eye's death. Whoops! Move on! Bye, Alastor! Well, not even that.

Worse, Molly — one of the most criminally short-changed characters in this series of movies — doesn't try to do anything for her terribly injured son George except look sadly at him. She doesn't even clean off the blood! And what exactly happened to George? I still see his ear, under all the blood.

Also, Harry gets over Hedwig's death a lot faster than he does Dobby's. 

And what's with the Bathilda Bagshot sequence? It's pretty terrific and creepy... until Nagini apparently tries to kill Harry. What's that about? Voldemort stressed that he had to be the one to kill Harry Potter. So Nagini's gone rogue? Unlikely. Why not just do it as in the book, have Nagini trying to hold Harry until Voldemort's arrival, with Hermione once again saving their lives, if just barely?

The Lovegood sequence also seems not-fully-thought-through. Xenophilius says Luna will be along shortly... then everyone forgets about her. Tea is made, stories are told, the day goes on, and no one asks, "So, where is Luna, anyway?" — as they do in the book. So why do the Death Eaters apparently immediately start setting about destroying Lovegood's place, when he was trying to turn in Harry Potter? If the Death Eaters had killed Harry, wouldn't Voldemort have gone medieval on them? Doesn't make sense.

But then again, so much is done so well: the seven Harry's, the flight from the Death Eaters, Ron's return. The three actors who play the trio Polyjuiced at the Ministry are absolutely wonderful. As I said, even the additions are good, particularly Hermione Obliviating her parents, Ron and Hermione at the piano, and Harry dancing with Hermione.

Terrific movie, best of the lot.

Hope the final one hews even closer to the book. If Molly doesn't get her big scene, I'll be royally cheesed.


Monday, November 08, 2010

"Hereafter" — movie review

Movie: Hereafter
Length: 2469 min (we say; they say 129 min)
Rated: PG-13
Starring: Matt Damon, Cécile De France Bryce Dallas Howard, you won't care who else
Director: Clint Eastwood

Don't you hate it when someone tells a really, really long joke — and it's a bad joke? While it goes on and on and on, you're thinking, "Oh my gosh, here's ___ minutes of my life I'll never have back... I hope at least it's a good punchline."

And then it isn't. Don't you hate that?

Weirder when it's a person who usually tells pretty good jokes. You wonder what happened, what was that about, how could he have thought that was funny?

Hereafter is like that. Director Clint Eastwood knows how to make good movies. This isn't one of them.

My dear wife and I went because Michael Medved absolutely raved about the movie. Medved said lead actor Matt Damon's performance is "simply magnificent," "a career-topper" — the relativity of which should have warned me. More, the viewer would be "fascinated," and every scene would pay off. What moved me to see it in a theater rather than on DVD is Medved's giddy bubbling that the opening of the movie was the most amazing in recent movie history, maybe (he added in live radio) the most amazing ever.

Really? More so than Star Wars (episode 4) or Saving Private Ryan or a dozen other movies with hit-the-ground-running openings? Wow. Plus, the ending (Medved assured) would be romantic, touching, unexpected, and utterly satisfying.

That last part is what stayed in my mind as we sat through meandering, plodding, predictable, listless scene after meandering, plodding, predictable, listless scene. "Yeah, but boy oh boy, the ending is going to be amazing!"

So I just started laughing incredulously as the camera started drawing back at the last scene's end, and when the screen went black. What? That was it? Did we just see the same movie Medved saw?

Here we become mildly spoilerific, an indulgence I allow when I am not going to recommend a movie, as I do not recommend this movie.

The opening was impressive, but it wasn't All That. The first moments are aimless, but when The Event happens — well, at first the CGI stood out as so-so CGI, not up to the standards of, say, Weta (who created Lord of the Rings' truly dazzling and seamless effects). But the latter half of the sequence is indeed an amazing ride, but it isn't "The Best Sequence Evah!"

What the opener does is set up a French reporter who has a near-death experience which changes her life. That's Main Character #1. After that, we meet Main Character #2, a British boy whose twin tragically dies, leaving him alone and heartbroken.

Main Character #3, "George" (played by Matt Damon), is meant to be the ultimately lynch-pin. If this Damon performance is a "career-topper," it can't be much of a career. What makes George almost interesting is that, thanks to childhood illness and surgeries, he's developed an ability which to him is a "curse." If he touches people, he can see and hear their dead loved ones. Ta-daa., that's it.

As George, Damon basically goes the movie sad and mopey and (wait for it) haunted. But not haunted in an interesting way. He isn't "haunted" like Michael J. Fox in The Frighteners, or like the little boy in The Sixth Sense. No, nothing whatever happens to him until he touches someone, and that's over in a minute or two. And that's George's big tragic curse. Again I say "ta," and I hasten to add "daa."

Don't wait for any great moment in any of these encounters, either. There are about four of them, at most, and none is really significant. No climaxes, no great mysteries solved, no deep truths unearthed. Significant only to the person to whom George relays the messages, and in the first two cases, that person instantly leaves the movie. Nothing larger is built on it or comes from it. It's really nothing.


So, back to the three Main Characters. They're all on different continents. You think, "Whoa, if these three come together, it's got to be really dramatic and gob-smacking!"

Well, then: Do the three geographically far-parted characters ultimately come together? What do you think? And when they do, is it by interesting and dramatic circumstances? And is the coming-together dramatic and epic — is it gob-smacking? And is the ultimate pay-off unexpected and satisfying?

To the last three, No, No, and In no way. The ending is totally predictable, makes no particular sense, and gives no real resolution of any consequence. (The viewer isn't even sure whether George comforts the little boy by lying to him; it sure looks as if he does.)

Is there anything involving about the movie? Anything at all? Yes. The little boy's story is compelling in places; his relationship with his brother is sweet, though brief.

But Damon and Cécile De France just are not that interesting. In fact, bit-players are more interesting, including the boy's drug-wrecked mother (played by Lyndsey Marshal), a random woman who begs unsuccessfully for George's help... and Bryce Dallas Howard, who briefly plays a failed love-interest.

I pause to say that Howard (daughter of actor/director Ron Howard) is a remarkable actress. I have seen her in maybe a half-dozen movies, and I never recognize her unless I know in advance that she's in the movie. She vanishes into her roles. You think, "Oh yes, she's this sort of an actress" — until her next movie, when she is totally different.

I had no idea this character was Howard. I was thinking the actress was very capable in that role, but wondered if she was limited to twitchy, hyper parts. Then her crowning scene was just perfectly executed, and I thought, "Hm, not bad." Turns out it was not "not bad," it was perfect. It was Howard, once again so disappearing into a character that you think she was born to play it and only it. Then you think that same thing again of the next totally different character. And the next. And the next.

But even Howard can't save this movie, nor can the other actors or the beautiful scenery. The uninspired, random music doesn't help, either.

You may be thinking, "Oh, yes, all this is because you're a guy. There weren't enough explosions and fist-fights and beheadings for you." To that I simply reply that, if possible, my dear wife liked the movie less than I did — and I didn't like it.

I did learn another emergency technique, however. I mean, The Abyss taught me that if you yell at dead people loud enough along with brutalizing their bodies, sometimes they revive. Now Hereafter adds that if you just give up on a dead person and go watch something else for a minute, sometimes the corpse will just cough up some water and be A-OK. Cool. I can do that.

Does the movie at least present some thoughts worth pondering? After all, it is about death. If you think about it, every one of us is going to spend a whole lot more time dead than we ever spent alive. Should be at least interesting.

No, really, it doesn't and isn't. Not of itself. It purveys the usual Hollywood desperate-hope/myth that everything's going to turn out OK for everyone, even child molesters — the one category Hollywood usually still vilifies, even while playing to it by the sexualization of ever-younger girls — who were impenitent in this life.

There is no God in this movie. One character on a video tells viewers that if they believe in Christ, they've nothing to fear in death. The little boy, who was viewing it, shakes his head and moves on.

This was actually the least-surprising and least-disappointing element to me. Is that in itself surprising? It shouldn't be. We should all of us know never to look to Hollywood for answers. It has none to give, and the answers it thinks it has are all wrong. Its "gospel" is "trust your heart and everything will work out just terrific."

Well, we shouldn't, and it won't. Our hearts are grand deceivers (Jeremiah 17:9). Everything won't work out fine for everyone, because God is a specific Person with specific values and demands, and the absolute right both to have and require them. What's more, He has the relentless power to enforce them.

Atheists rage against this; we all naturally do. We want to be ultimate. If there even is a God, we want Him simply to be there to back our plays and clean up our messes. After that, we want Him to go to His room and leave us to follow our hearts.

One note in the movie, however, brushes near the truth — and then moves right past it. A character says that, if there were life after death, we should expect that someone would have discovered something and reported it back to us.

You want to stop the movie right there and say, "Yeah, wouldn't that be great? If, say, someone were as dead as Julius Caesar, buried, cold and gone... for a day, or two, or even three? And then came back, more alive than ever before, in the flesh? Wouldn't that change everything?"

But, you see, as a matter of fact that has happened. And it really does change everything.

Except Hollywood's willful blindness, and its fascination with itself.

If you'd like to learn more truth about that, you can read it here — but not in "Hereafter."